Question
Finding where x ln x is decreasing using the derivative
Original question: Let be the function defined by for . On what open interval is decreasing?
A only
B
C
D There is no such interval.
Expert Verified Solution
Key concept: This calculus question asks for the interval of decrease of a function defined on . The solution depends on taking the derivative, analyzing its sign, and linking that sign to monotonicity.
Step by step
Differentiate the function
The function is
Use the product rule:
So
Find where the derivative is negative
A function is decreasing where its derivative is negative. So we solve
This gives
and exponentiating both sides yields
Because the domain is , the interval of decrease is
Match to the correct choice
The correct option is
Why the sign of the derivative matters
For one-variable calculus, the derivative tells you the slope of the tangent line. When , the graph slopes downward as increases, which means the function is decreasing. Here, crosses zero at , so the function decreases to the left of that point and increases to the right.
A quick sign test confirms this: if , then ; if , then . That pattern matches the interval found above.
Pitfall alert
A common mistake is differentiating as or forgetting the product rule entirely. Another issue is solving and writing , which is impossible because on the domain. The exponential step must be handled carefully: from , you get , not . It is also easy to forget the domain restriction , but that restriction is essential because is not defined for nonpositive .
Try different conditions
If the function were , then the derivative would be , and the function would be decreasing when , that is, . If the question asked for where the function is increasing instead, you would solve , giving . The method stays the same: differentiate first, then analyze the sign of the derivative on the domain.
Further reading
product rule, derivative sign test, interval of decrease
Got the method? Make it stick.
FAQ
How do you determine where the function x ln x is decreasing?
Differentiate using the product rule to get f'(x)=ln x+1, then solve f'(x)<0. This gives 0<x<1/e.
Why does a negative derivative mean the function is decreasing?
A negative derivative means the slope of the graph is negative, so the function values go down as x increases on that interval.