Question

Finding where x ln x is decreasing using the derivative

Original question: Let ff be the function defined by f(x)=xlnxf(x)=x\ln x for x>0x>0. On what open interval is ff decreasing?

A 0<x<1e0<x<\frac{1}{e} only

B 0<x<10<x<1

C x>1ex>\frac{1}{e}

D There is no such interval.

Expert Verified Solution

thumb_up100%(1 rated)

Key concept: This calculus question asks for the interval of decrease of a function defined on x>0x>0. The solution depends on taking the derivative, analyzing its sign, and linking that sign to monotonicity.

Step by step

Differentiate the function

The function is

f(x)=xlnx,x>0.f(x)=x\ln x,\quad x>0.

Use the product rule:

f(x)=1lnx+x1x.f'(x)=1\cdot \ln x + x\cdot \frac{1}{x}.

So

f(x)=lnx+1.f'(x)=\ln x+1.

Find where the derivative is negative

A function is decreasing where its derivative is negative. So we solve

lnx+1<0.\ln x+1<0.

This gives

lnx<1,\ln x<-1,

and exponentiating both sides yields

x<e1=1e.x<e^{-1}=\frac{1}{e}.

Because the domain is x>0x>0, the interval of decrease is

0<x<1e.\boxed{0<x<\frac{1}{e}}.

Match to the correct choice

The correct option is

A.\boxed{A}.

Why the sign of the derivative matters

For one-variable calculus, the derivative tells you the slope of the tangent line. When f(x)<0f'(x)<0, the graph slopes downward as xx increases, which means the function is decreasing. Here, lnx+1\ln x+1 crosses zero at x=1/ex=1/e, so the function decreases to the left of that point and increases to the right.

A quick sign test confirms this: if x=0.1x=0.1, then ln(0.1)+1<0\ln(0.1)+1<0; if x=1x=1, then ln(1)+1=1>0\ln(1)+1=1>0. That pattern matches the interval found above.

Pitfall alert

A common mistake is differentiating xlnxx\ln x as lnx/x\ln x/x or forgetting the product rule entirely. Another issue is solving lnx+1<0\ln x+1<0 and writing x<1/ex< -1/e, which is impossible because x>0x>0 on the domain. The exponential step must be handled carefully: from lnx<1\ln x<-1, you get x<e1x<e^{-1}, not x<e1x<-e^{-1}. It is also easy to forget the domain restriction x>0x>0, but that restriction is essential because lnx\ln x is not defined for nonpositive xx.

Try different conditions

If the function were f(x)=xlnx2xf(x)=x\ln x-2x, then the derivative would be f(x)=lnx1f'(x)=\ln x-1, and the function would be decreasing when lnx<1\ln x<1, that is, 0<x<e0<x<e. If the question asked for where the function is increasing instead, you would solve lnx+1>0\ln x+1>0, giving x>1/ex>1/e. The method stays the same: differentiate first, then analyze the sign of the derivative on the domain.

Further reading

product rule, derivative sign test, interval of decrease

FAQ

How do you determine where the function x ln x is decreasing?

Differentiate using the product rule to get f'(x)=ln x+1, then solve f'(x)<0. This gives 0<x<1/e.

Why does a negative derivative mean the function is decreasing?

A negative derivative means the slope of the graph is negative, so the function values go down as x increases on that interval.

chat