Question

Prove that the bodies do not meet

Original question: (c) Prove that the bodies do not meet.                         (2 marks)

Expert Verified Solution

thumb_up100%(1 rated)

Key concept: To prove two moving bodies do not meet, check whether their separation can ever be zero. Here the distance formula makes that test straightforward.

Step by step

To meet, the distance between the bodies must be 00 for some real value of tt.

From part (b), the distance is

5t2+40t+100\sqrt{5t^2+40t+100}

So we would need

5t2+40t+100=05t^2+40t+100=0

Divide by 5:

t2+8t+20=0t^2+8t+20=0

Now check the discriminant:

Δ=824(1)(20)=6480=16\Delta=8^2-4(1)(20)=64-80=-16

Since the discriminant is negative, this quadratic has no real roots. Therefore there is no real time tt for which the distance is zero.

Conclusion

The bodies do not meet.

The bodies do not meet\boxed{\text{The bodies do not meet}}

Pitfall alert

A common mistake is to assume that because the distance formula is available, the bodies must meet at the time when the expression is smallest. The minimum distance is not the same as zero distance.

Try different conditions

Another way is to complete the square:

5t2+40t+100=5(t2+8t+20)=5((t+4)2+4)5t^2+40t+100=5(t^2+8t+20)=5\bigl((t+4)^2+4\bigr)

This is always at least 2020, so the distance is always at least 20\sqrt{20}, never zero.

Further reading

discriminant, quadratic equation, minimum distance

FAQ

Why do the bodies not meet?

The distance between them is never zero because the equation for zero distance has no real solution.

How can the discriminant show that they do not meet?

If the quadratic equation for zero distance has a negative discriminant, it has no real roots, so no real time gives distance zero.

chat