Question
How to estimate a derivative, use the Intermediate Value Theorem, and compute trapezoidal and accumulation approximations
Original question: 3. A student starts reading a book at time $t=0$ minutes and continues reading for the next 10 minutes. The rate at which the student reads is modeled by the differentiable function $R$, where $R(t)$ is measured in words per minute. Selected values of $R(t)$ are given in the table shown. $$ \begin{array}{c|cccc} t\, (\text{minutes}) & 0 & 2 & 8 & 10 \\ \hline R(t)\, (\text{words per minute}) & 90 & 100 & 150 & 162 \end{array} $$ A. Approximate $R'(1)$ using the average rate of change of $R$ over the interval $0\le t\le 2$. Show the work that leads to your answer. Indicate units of measure. B. Must there be a value $c$, for $0<c<10$, such that $R(c)=155$? Justify your answer. C. Use a trapezoidal sum with the three subintervals indicated by the data in the table to approximate the value of $\int_0^{10} R(t)\,dt$. Show the work that leads to your answer. D. A teacher also starts reading at time $t=0$ minutes and continues reading for the next 10 minutes. The rate at which the teacher reads is modeled by the function $W$ defined by $W(t)=-\frac{3}{10}t^2+8t+100$, where $W(t)$ is measured in words per minute. Based on the model, how many words has the teacher read by the end of the 10 minutes? Show the work that leads to your answer.
Expert Verified Solution
Key concept: This is the kind of free-response problem where each part tests a different skill. The trick is to stay organized: local rate, existence, numerical integration, then a model-based accumulation calculation.
Step by step
A. Approximate
Use the average rate of change of on :
So
B. Must there be a value such that ?
Yes.
From the table:
Because is differentiable, it is continuous on . Since 155 lies between 150 and 162, the Intermediate Value Theorem guarantees at least one value in with
So the answer is
C. Trapezoidal sum for
Use the intervals , , and .
So
D. Words read by the teacher
The teacher's rate is
The total words read in 10 minutes is
Compute:
=\left[-\frac{1}{10}t^3+4t^2+100t\right]_0^{10}.$$ At $t=10$: $$-\frac{1}{10}(1000)+4(100)+100(10)=-100+400+1000=1300.$$ At $t=0$: $$0.$$ So the teacher read $$\boxed{1300\text{ words}}.$$ ### Final answers - $\boxed{R'(1)\approx 5}$ - $\boxed{\text{Yes, by IVT}}$ - $\boxed{1252\text{ words}}$ - $\boxed{1300\text{ words}}$ ### Pitfall alert For part A, don't divide by 1 just because you are asked for $R'(1)$; the table only gives an estimate, so you use the slope over the nearest interval. For part C, another frequent mistake is forgetting to multiply each trapezoid average by its interval width. That changes the answer a lot. ### Try different conditions If the table had included more points, a Simpson's Rule estimate might be more accurate than the trapezoidal sum. If part D had asked for the average reading rate instead of total words, you would divide the integral by 10 after computing it. ### Further reading Intermediate Value Theorem, trapezoidal sum, accumulation functionFAQ
How do you estimate R'(1) from a table?
Use the average rate of change on the nearest interval, here [0,2], giving (100-90)/2 = 5.
Why does the Intermediate Value Theorem apply in part B?
Because R is differentiable, it is continuous, and 155 lies between the table values 150 and 162.