Text 1: Critic Park argues that fairy tales serve a psychologically valuable function. By dramatizing fears in symbolic form — the devouring wolf, the wicked stepmother — they help children process emotions safely. To sanitize traditional fairy tales, Park contends, is to deprive children of useful tools for emotional growth.
Text 2: Critic Singh accepts that fairy tales address fears but questions the "useful tool" framing. Many traditional tales also transmit values children would be better off without — passivity in girls, cruelty as virtue. Adapting tales for modern audiences, Singh argues, is not sanitization but a long tradition of selecting which lessons to keep.
The authors most clearly disagree about
- A
whether fairy tales feature wolves.
- B
whether fairy tales address children's fears.
- Ccheck_circle
whether traditional fairy tales should be adapted or preserved unchanged.
- D
whether children have emotions.
Explanation
Both accept that fairy tales address fears. They differ on adaptation. B captures the dispute.